About Us

About Us

Benson Thomson Agency, Inc. is Morris County’s oldest family owned and operated independent insurance agency.  We have been serving northern New Jersey since 1921.  We represent nationally recognized insurance carriers known for the strength and financial security to give you confidence when protecting your assets.  You can expect personal attention to identify your individual needs, explain the coverages available, and get a competitive quote. Should you experience an unfortunate loss, you can expect us to respond quickly to your needs and help you through the claim process.  Our goal is to get you a fair settlement in a timely manner.

At Benson Thomson Agency we treat our customers like family.

A Brief History
Samuel Gibson our founder created a real-estate and insurance agency business in 1921 in Dover, New Jersey. Sam was very active and involved in the community. Years past and in 1948 the family business was sold to Oscar W. Benson who continued to expand the Agency. In 1950 the business was growing and Stephen Thomson joined the Agency working with Oscar Benson, as the surrounding communities expanded in and around Dover. With continued growth in 1957 a new location was needed for the business and they moved from their Blackwell Street location to its current location at 15 North Morris Street. Stephen Thomson in 1961 partnered with Oscar Benson and they incorporated under the name Benson Thomson Agency, Inc.  In 1986 Jay Thomson joined his father in the family insurance business and is now running the day to day operations of the Agency.

We have been providing insurance to families and businesses in Northern New Jersey’s, Morris County and surrounding Counties for over 85 years!  Since then, we have gained the trust of our clients throughout the years and for some area families it’s been generations. As an Independent Insurance Agency, we continue to follow the same path of success that Sam Gibson, Oscar Benson, Steve Thomson and Jay Thomson have done, by maintaining and creating stable long term client relationships and will do so for the years to come.
Competitive Pricing
Benson Thomson Agency is an Independent Insurance Agent. Meaning that our agency represents a number of insurance companies that provides us with many alternative routes when trying to select the best possible coverage and pricing for our clients.

Great Service
At Benson Thomson Agency we are dedicated to providing our customers with quick, professional and friendly service. We pride ourselves on being available to our clients to help them with any concerns they might have about their insurance. We maintain a complete copy of your insurance policy and schedules in our office so we can review and service your account within a moment's notice. Our computers enable us to provide prompt service and quotes for all types of insurance.

Our Community
Benson Thomson Agency has a long history of involvement in the community and giving back, by supporting local organizations like Rotary International, the Kiwanis International, the Little League, Boys Scouts of America, Girls Scouts of America, the Dover Chamber of Commerce, the Morris / Sussex County Independent Agents, the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of New Jersey, and Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America. 

Oscar Benson expanded his role in the community over the years  leading by example as he was the past President of the Morris County Board of Realtors, on the Board of trustees at Dover General Hospital,  President of Randolph Building and Loan (now a part of Sovereign Bank), and served on the Board of National Union Bank (now part of JP Morgan Chase).

The Agency has been honored over the years for its involvement as Stephen Thomson was honored by Rotary International of Dover for his outstanding community service in 1988, the Dover Chamber of Commerce as Business man of the year in October of 1993, and later became a George F. Hixson Fellow with Kiwanis International in October of 1998.  Honors aside, Stephen Thomson served as the Treasurer of Mine Hill from 1948 to 1976 and still found some time to volunteer as a Little League Coach and a recreation department girl’s softball coach.

Jay Thomson enjoys spending some of his time helping to safeguard the natural resources and enhance the quality of life in Morris County by serving on the Morris County Open Space and Farmland Preservation Trust Fund committees. The Board of chosen Freeholders, Morris County selected Jay in November of 2003 to be honored for his years of dedicated  service to Morris County for his role as chairman of the above committees.  Jay has contributed to several other areas of the community by supporting Kiwanis International, now a life member; is past President Dover Kiwanis Club and an Advisor to Dover High School's Key Club.  He supports the local Dover Chamber of Commerce as a trustee, been given the Award Merit by the Boy Scouts of America Black River District for his role on the Patriots Path Council and has worked with scouting in Randolph as a Cubmaster of Pack 50 and now as an assistant Scoutmaster to Troup 50. 

We look forward to you joining our family of clients.

Benson Thomson Agency, Inc. is licensed in the state of New Jersey.  This website is only intended for the use of residents in this state, and is not intended as a solicitation or offer of insurance in any other state or where such offer would be a violation of law.